---
title: Critic-Verifier AI Agent Pattern for Policy & Fact QA
description: Implement a critic-verifier AI agent pattern to audit factual grounding, policy compliance, and tone before sending high-stakes chatbot answers.
canonical: "https://botsquad.ai/j/build-critic-verifier-agent-output-review"
modified: 2026-11-14
author: botsquad.ai editorial team
source: "https://botsquad.ai"
category: Multi-Agent Architecture & Orchestration
category_url: "https://botsquad.ai/j#group-multi-agent-orchestration"
---

# Add a critic-verifier agent to check drafts before user delivery

> Run fast automated compliance, citation, and policy checks on high-stakes chatbot drafts before the customer ever sees the reply.

## Prepared starting prompt

We need a lightweight verifier agent to inspect outbound billing and SLA answers for ungrounded claims before sending them to enterprise users.

### Quick scenarios
- **SLA & legal promise checker:** Block outbound bot drafts that promise custom uptime SLAs or unapproved fee waivers.
- **Citation match verifier:** Verify every quoted policy number actually appears in the retrieved RAG chunks.
- **Selective high-risk gating:** Trigger the critic agent only on billing, security, and cancellation intents to save latency.

- [Request Early BotSquad Access](https://botsquad.ai/#waitlist-14a5d2)

## How to deploy a low-latency critic-verifier agent

1. **Scope verification to high-stakes intents** — Run synchronous verifier passes on pricing, refunds, compliance, and technical commands while letting simple greetings stream immediately.
2. **Grade against a binary rubric** — Give the critic three concrete pass/fail checks—source alignment, prohibited promises, and PII leakage—instead of vague quality critiques.
3. **Cap revision cycles at one rewrite** — Allow a single targeted regeneration with critic feedback; if the second draft still fails, return a safe fallback or escalate.
4. **Use a fast lightweight judge model** — Pair your primary generator with a compact, low-latency classifier or small reasoning model so verification adds under 600ms.

## How it works in practice

### Primary bot draft vs retrieved policy

Retrieved doc: 'Annual plans are non-refundable after 14 days.' Draft reply: 'No problem! I can prorate a refund for your remaining 7 months right away.'

### Critic-verifier interception

Status: BLOCKED (Rule: prohibited_refund_promise, Source contradiction). Rewrite instruction: State the 14-day annual refund policy clearly and offer human billing review for exceptional account circumstances.

A 400ms verifier check prevents binding financial misstatements before a single token reaches the customer widget.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Doesn't a critic agent break token-by-token response streaming?

For gated high-risk intents, buffer the short reply or stream a brief status indicator while the fast verifier validates policy compliance.

### Should the critic agent use the same LLM family as the generator?

Using a distinct model family or deterministic rule hybrid reduces correlated blind spots where the same model overlooks its own hallucination.

### How do we measure whether our verifier agent is worth the extra cost?

Track interception rate on live traffic alongside false-positive blocks during weekly QA sampling to verify net error reduction.

## Learn more

- [Professional advice chatbots: their strengths and critical limits](https://botsquad.ai/get-professional-advice-chatbot.md)
- [When to trust AI assistants for professional advice](https://botsquad.ai/ai-assistant-for-professional-advice.md)
- [AI chatbot automated task schedulers: capabilities and limitations](https://botsquad.ai/ai-chatbot-automated-task-scheduler.md)
- [9 truths about educational chatbot tutoring tools reshaping classrooms](https://botsquad.ai/educational-chatbot-tutoring-tools.md)
- [AI chatbot for automated customer support: what succeeds and what fails](https://botsquad.ai/ai-chatbot-for-automated-customer-support.md)
- [How AI chatbots amplify creative ideation and workflow](https://botsquad.ai/ai-chatbot-creative-process-enhancement.md)

## Related tasks in this category

- [Design a supervisor-router architecture for specialist AI chatbots](https://botsquad.ai/j/design-supervisor-router-agent-architecture.md)
- [Prevent infinite loops and ping-ponging between AI agents](https://botsquad.ai/j/prevent-infinite-loops-multi-agent-handoffs.md)
- [Define a shared session memory schema across specialist bots](https://botsquad.ai/j/define-shared-state-memory-schema-agent-teams.md)
- [Orchestrate parallel sub-agents for research and synthesis workflows](https://botsquad.ai/j/configure-parallel-subagent-research-synthesis.md)
- [Scope API and tool-calling permissions for each specialist agent](https://botsquad.ai/j/set-tool-calling-permissions-per-specialist-bot.md)
- [Refactor a bloated monolithic bot into focused domain specialists](https://botsquad.ai/j/split-monolithic-prompt-into-specialist-bots.md)

---

*Published by **Wondel.ai sp. z o.o.** · [botsquad.ai](https://botsquad.ai) · [About](https://botsquad.ai/about) · [Editorial Guidelines](https://botsquad.ai/editorial) · [Contact](https://botsquad.ai/contact) · [Wondel.ai Products](https://wondel.ai/products)*